Category Archives: government

Is there a silver lining to the rupee crunch?

It’s obvious that a lot of people are worried about the rupee crunch that’s upon us Bhutanese this spring. People have children in India who they have to send money to, businessmen are worried about imports, vegetable vendors are complaining about the increased value of the rupee compared to the ngultrum and subsequently the increased price of the vegetables, everyone is worried about inflation, people who are halfway through constructing buildings are having a hard time completing their work, and the crisis may threaten the ngultrum-rupee peg itself.

But is there a flip side to the whole crisis? We have been aware for a very long time, that we have a very unhealthy practice of buying almost everything from India, while not selling enough to it, and this rupee crisis is a result of that lack of self sustenance. Will the rupee shortage force us to become a little more self sufficient?

I mentioned an interesting conversation with a friend in my last post, and he certainly thinks so. He cites the example of the lack of eggs due to the bird flu scares, and how that has led to a complete replacement of imported (and inferior quality) eggs with local eggs, and how, despite the increase in price, people still eat eggs.  In fact, he says, people won’t want to go back to eating the small white eggs again, even if they are cheaply available in the market. Sounds like a success story.

So, will that happen? When we find that Indian vegetables and other commodities are no longer available in the market, or are as expensive as the local ones because of the informal increase in rupee value, will people start consuming local goods, thus replacing the imported goods with local goods permanently?

I don’t know. I sure hope so, but I also get the nagging feeling that it isn’t going be all that automatic as my friend suggests. We can work this situation into an advantage, and use it to boost our local economy, but that definitely needs some active, conscious action.

We should have been able to replace imported items with local ones already. Local products are supposedly of better quality, healthier, and tastier. So why hasn’t the average Bhutanese preferred local goods to imported ones? Of course, reasons vary for different items, but lets talk food products here.

The first answer is probably because of the higher cost of local goods. The higher cost can be attributed to lack of competition among the local produce, and that, in turn to the small yield from farms. I may be wrong- I have heard of people having to throw away vegetables (potatoes) because they couldn’t sell it all off. But in general, I feel I am right in this. Obviously, this is conjecture, and the concerned agency needs to look at why local produce is not main source of food for us.

Incidentally, who is the concerned agency? The agriculture ministry, for now, but it’s about time we had an agency which looked solely at how to boost local economy through agriculture. Not just boost agriculture, or cottage industries, but economy through agriculture. This body can be small, and work with various other organisations, but work solely to ensure that our farmers grow more, grow for business, find ways to turn more and more farm produce into marketable goods, ensure that the products are of a certain quality, and also to help them market their goods.

The agriculture ministry probably works at helping farmers produce more. But something is definitely going wrong somewhere in between when this work doesn’t translate into results. What happened, for instance, to the three crop policy that was introduced a few years ago?

We need to look at the real problems of our farmers. Do they have the right seeds, the right breed of animals, the right knowledge to grow these crops and rear the animals? Do they have enough land, enough fertilizers, enough water to irrigate their lands? Do they have roads to help them transport their goods to the outlets? Are there enough cooperatives that help them sell their produce? Or are our farmers just lazy? We aren’t really a lot of people to feed, smaller and more difficult lands have been able to feed larger population than ours.

The rupee crisis may open the eyes of our farmers to the opportunity to market their locally grown produce, and eventually replace all imported farm produce- it may hide a silver lining.  But it may not work out that way, unless active steps are taken. We can wait and watch, or we can make it happen.

Meanwhile, you can do your bit to enhance this ‘silver lining’ by consciously choosing local products- local milk, butter, cheese, salt, vegetables, locally produced snacks (a lot of locally produced potato chips, fried nuts, fried snacks, and even fried tengma is available in town, and they are probably more healthier than MSG filled imported snacks), packaged drinks, and furniture.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Bhutan, Entrepreneurship, government, new ventures, Uncategorized

say no to smart people

Let’s see how the smartest people are punished and scorned in Bhutan. In our country, once upon a time in the not so distant past, MBBS was a goal for every science student. The few who did qualify suddenly attained Olympian status. Six years of studying, and then, one of the most prestigious careers in Bhutan, a doctor. It was what every parent wanted for their children.
We all agree that we need great doctors. We need the smartest and most capable people to take care of our health. We need these people. Yet, how are these people treated? We all know the tired stories of the doctors in Bhutan.
Like an eerie parallel to what happened in the book, the government is committing one crime upon another over the smart and capable people.
Every year, the competition is tough, we all know, for MBBS slots. There were many people who did not get the scholarship just by a point.
They were smart children, who had worked hard, and deserved it. But, what to do, said the government. Competition is tough these days, anyways.
Really? Is competition so tough? Or is there any competition at all?
Take the example of the students who could not qualify for MBBS, but were still forced to go by their over zealous parents. Hope they are not having such a tough time managing their studies. Now, you would say, it is every man’s right to study whatever he wants in life. Sure, sure. I would not criticize the people who have opted to do MBBS on their own. I would feel a little sorry for those who feel they simply can’t cope up, and those who are smart but didn’t make it through the scholarship selections, well, they had a fair chance and lost. They have no one to blame but themselves.
But what is this about the government awarding scholarships to these private students, in the name of doing a greater good, (ie, addressing doctor shortage in the country). Why, do you think, do the best medical schools in the world have a cutoff point? Why does any institute have cutoff points? Does a degree from any shoddy college, or from a college you got into, not because you were good enough but because you had the money or connections, make you a good doctor? Money can buy a degree but it can’t buy brains.
We need great doctors. We need smart people to heal us. But we don’t want the smart people to make all the money. We don’t want the best people to have an easy life. That is the government’s motto. And also, we reward mediocre people, because they are mediocre. And we give to those who don’t need it, not because they deserve it, but because….well, frankly speaking, I don’t know why.
Because they are related to some of the politicians? That is what I hear, but I doubt that just because the patient is your uncle, you will be able to summon skills that you never had to cure him. I am sure the politicians who made this decision will always remember which ones are the private doctors, and ask to be seen by someone else. Eh?
But what will we do when all the good doctors are too tired to do their best, and the only ones we can turn to are the “private students” educated by the government, who refused to educate some of the smart people? I think I will seek medical care elsewhere in the world.
This is the worst decision of the present government, including the pay hike proposal that worked its way top down.

2 Comments

Filed under government, private MBBS students stipend